Serbia, Georgia, and their Breakaway Regions:  Examining the Socio-political Mirror Imagery

Miloš Petrović

doi:10.52340/sou.2022.20.14

Authors

Miloš Petrović Institute of International Politics and Economic

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.52340/sou.2022.20.14

Keywords:

Kosovo, Abkhazia, secession, Orthodoxy, history, international relations, strategy

Abstract

The author examines various aspects of historical and socio-political developments in Georgia and Serbia with specific emphasis on their breakaway regions (Abkhazia and Kosovo, respectively). It is argued that Tbilisi and Belgrade have been facing some similar issues and dilemmas, which are correlated with their historical experiences, coupled with significant exposure to damaging external influences and shifting trends in international politics and law. Major parallels (and to a lesser degree, dissimilarities) are analyzed through historical and comparative methods, with additional contributions from political science theories and practice, while also bearing in mind that analogies cannot be made in absolute, but rather, relative terms. The author deploys the ambiguous “mirror image” concept to point out the interpenetration between these similarities and dissimilarities, that have ultimately resulted in certain comparable outcomes, not only regarding the unfavorable situation in the seceded regions but also, in the context of the two nations’ recent strategic paths.

References

Anjaparidze, Z. (2022). Zaal Anjaparidze. Russia Redeploys Troops From Its Bases in Georgia to Ukraine. Eurasia Daily Monitor 19(42). Date of Access on February 3, 2023, and available at: https://jamestown.org/program/russia-redeploys-troops-from-its-bases-in-georgia-to-ukraine/.

Athanasiadis, A. (2017). Athanasios Athanasiadis. Saint Sava Nemanjić as a Messenger and Founder of the Eastern Church Tradition in the Serbian Church. Fragmenta Hellenoslavica 4/2017, 9-25.

Axboe Nielsen, C. (2009). Christian Axboe Nielsen. The Kosovo precedent and the rhetorical deployment of former Yugoslav analogies in the cases of Abk¬ha¬zia and South Ossetia. Journal of Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 9 (1): 171-189.

Bataković, D. (2017). Dušan, Bataković. The case of Kosovo: Separation vs. Integration Legacy, Identity, Nationalism. STUDIA ŚRODKOWOEUROPEJSKIE I BAŁKANISTYCZNE XXVI, 105-123.

Bloomberg News. (2022). Transcript: Vladimir Putin’s Televised Address on Ukraine. 2022, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-24/full-tra-nscript-vladimir-putin-s-televised-address-to-russia-on-ukraine-feb-24.

Charney, J. (1999). Jonathan Charney. Anticipatory Humanitarian Intervention in Kosovo, Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law 32(5): 1231-1248.

Chkhikvadze, N. (2020). Nestan Chkhikvadze. Georgian Manuscript Book (5th-19th centuries). (Second revised edition). Tbilisi, Publisher: Korneli Kekelidze Georgian Centre of Manuscripts.

Collins Dictionary. (2023). Mirror image. 2023 (https://www.collinsdic¬tionar-y.com/dictionary/english/mirror-image).

Cohn, M. (2002). Marjorie Cohn. NATO bombing of Kosovo: humanitarian intervention or crime against humanity? International Journal for the Semiotics of Law 15: 79–106.

Conroy. K. (2015). Kristina Conroy. Semi-Recognized States and Ambiguous Churches: The Orthodox Church in South Ossetia and Abkhazia. Journal of Chu¬rch and State 57(4): 621-639.

Đukanović, D. 2015. Dragan Đukanović. SFR Jugoslavija i Evropska ekonomska zajednica: od uspešne saradnje i potencijalnog članstva do suspenzije svih sporazuma. YU Historija. Retrieved February 1, 2023, from http://www.-yuhistorija.com/serbian/medj_politika_txt00c1.html.

Euronews. (2021). Czech President Milos Zeman apologises to Serbia for 1999 NATO bombing. 2021, https://www.euronews.com/2021/05/19/czech-president-milos-zeman-apologises-to-serbia-for-1999-nato-bombing.

European Council. (2022). Meeting of the European Political Community, 6 October 2022. Prague, 2022, https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/meetin-gs/international-summit/2022/10/06/.

Falkowski, M. (2014). Russia’s „Neighbourhood Policy“: the case of Abkhazia. Warsaw, 2014, https://www.osw.waw.pl/en/publikacje/analyses/2014-11-26/russias-neighbourhood-policy-case-abkhazia.

Gogonaia, I. (2018). Irina Gogonaia. „Lifelong learning“ and opportunities of non-formal education in the National Centre of Manuscripts. p. 62. Date of Access on January 25, 2023. and available at: https://ceca.mini.icom.muse-um/publications/conference-proceedings/.

Gogonaia, I., Kekelia, V. (2019). Irina Gogonaia, Vladimer Kekelia (Eds.). The Re-pousse Metal Covers of Georgian Manuscripts (second revised edition). Tbilisi, Korneli Kekelidze Georgian National Centre of Manuscripts;

Kalichava, K. (2021). Kakhaber Kalichava. Kosovo, Abkhazia, Tskhinvali region: The Historical and Comparative Analysis of Contemporary Conflicts. Tbilisi, Shota Rustaveli's Georgia National Science Foundation;

Kokrashvili, K. (2020). Khatuna Kokrashvili. Beginning of the Russian Occupation of Georgia: Abolition of Kartl-Kakheti and Imereti Kingdoms. In G. Cheishvili (Ed.), Russian expansion in the Caucasus and Georgia. (Series of articles). Tbilisi: Rondeli Foundation;

Komatina, P. (2015). Predrag Komatina. The church in Serbia at the time of Cyrilo – Methodian mission in Moravia, Cyril and Methodius: Byzantium and the World of the Slavs (pp. 711-718). Thessaloniki, publishing house „Thessprint S.A.“;

Kossev. (2021). State Department report on religious freedom: Decision on V. De-cani’s land still ignored, 57 incidents targeting religious sites. Kosovska Mitrovica, 2021, https://kossev.info/state-department-report-on-religious-freedom-decision-on-v-decanis-land-still-ignored-57-incidents-targeting-religious-sites/

Malcolm, N. (2020). Noel, Malcolm. Rebels, Believers, Survivors: Studies in the History of the Albanians. Oxford, Publishing House: Oxford University Press;

Metreveli, M. & Dallen, T. (2010). Marina Metreveli & Dallen Timothy. Religious heritage and emerging tourism in the Republic of Georgia. Journal of He¬ri-tage Tourism, 5(3), 237-244;

NATO. (1999). The accession of the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland. Bru-ssels, 1999,https://www.nato.int/docu/comm/1999/9904-wsh/preseng/03-acce-.pdf.

NATO. (2004). Seven new members join NATO. Brussels, 2004, https://www.nat-o.int/docu/update/2004/03-march/e0329a.htm.

Османова, Т. (2016). Тико Османова. Российская компания в монастыре Тири стёрла грузинские фрески. 2016, https://www.kavkazplus.co¬m/news¬.php-?id=2067#.Y-Sq3XbMK3A.

Papaskiri, Z. (2020). Zurab Papaskiri. On the national, political, ethnical and cultural identity of contemporary Abkhazia. Tbilisi, Publisher: Sokhumi State University;

Pavlovich, S. (2004). Stevan Pavlovich. Srbija: istorija iza imena. (English original print: Serbia: The History Behind the Name). Belgrade, Publishing House: Clio;

Pender, K. (2018). Abkhazians appreciate Syrian recognition, no matter the circumstances. New York, 2018, https://eurasianet.org/abkhazians-appreciatesyrian-recognition-no-matter-the-circumstances.

Petrović, M. (2018). Precedents - entering an unstable era. Belgrade, 2018, http://-ww¬w.transconflict.com/2018/11/precedents-entering-an-unstable-era-211/.

Petrović, M. (2021). Miloš Petrović. Vek od završetka Velikog rata: analitički osvrt na odabrana dokumenta iz istočnoevropske diplomatske istorije. Beograd: Institut za međunarodnu politiku i privredu;

Petrović, M. (2022a). Miloš Petrović. Nepovoljna perspektiva Istočnog partnerstva u pojedinim zemljama “evropskog susedstva”. Politikologija, 1(1), 1-20;

Petrović, M. (2022b). Miloš Petrović. European Union and Ukraine: the strategic partnership leading to (some)where? Međunarodni problemi/International Problems LXXIV(1): 75–101;

Radovanović, M. (1991). Milovan Radovanović. Antropogeografske i demografske osnove razvoja naseljenosti u Srbiji. In M. Zeremski (Ed.), Zbornik radova Geografskog instituta "Jovan Cvijić" 43 (pp. 57-91). Belgrade: SANU;

Ranke, L. (2004). Leopold Ranke. (Reprinted historical edition). Istorija srpske revolucije. Beograd: Srpska književna zadruga; Maretić, G. (1987). Gedeon Maretić. Istorija srpske revolucije (1804-1813). Beograd: Filip Višnjić;

Roeder, Ph. (1991). Philip Roeder. Soviet Federalism and Ethnic Mobilization. World Politics 43(2), 196-232;

Sampath Kumar, R. (2008). Rama Sampath Kumar. From Kosovo to Georgia: The US, NATO and Russia. Economic and Political Weekly 43(36): pp. 24-25, 27.

Sotirović, V. (2018). Vladislav, Sotirović. The Fundamental Misconception of the Balkan Ethnology: The ‚Illyrian‘ Theory of the Albanian Ethnogenesis. Hellenic Institute Foundation Policy Journal 9, 1−12;

Stojanović, M. (2023). Serbian President Claims ‘Nine More Kosovo Recognition Withdrawals’. Belgrade, 2023, https://balkaninsight.com/2023/01/05/serbi-an-presi¬dent-claims-nine-more-kosovo-recognition-withdrawals/.

Toft, M. (2003). Monica D. Toft. The Geography of Ethnic Violence: Identity, In-te¬rests, and the Indivisibility of Territory, pp. 87-106. Princeton: Princeton University Press;

United States Department of State (USDS). (1993). Georgia Human Rights Pra¬c-tices (1993). Washington, 1994 https://web.archive¬.org/web/20¬15062¬10¬60-939¬/h-ttp://dosfan.lib.uic.edu/ERC/democracy/1993_hrp_report/93hrp_report_eur/Georgia.html.

UNHCR. (2022). UNHCR in the Republic of Serbia. Belgrade, 2022, https://www.-unhcr.org/rs/en/unhcr-in-the-republic-of-serbia.

UNSCR. (2023). Search engine for the United Nations Security Council Resolutions. New York, 2023, http://unscr.com/.

Vučković, V. & Petrović, M. (2022). Vladimir Vučković, Miloš Petrović. Colliding Western Balkan Neighbors: Serbia and Montenegro in Post-Yugoslav Context–Identity and Interest Representation. Contemporary Southeastern Europe 9(2), 54-80;

annis, A. (2009). Alexandros Yannis. The politics and geopolitics of the status of Kosovo: the circle is never round. Southeast European and Black Sea Studies 9(1–2), 161–170;

Živković, T. (2010). Tibor Živković. Constantine Porphyrogenitus’ Source on the Ea¬rliest History of the Croats and Serbs. RADOVI 42, 117-131.